> My wife double checked because she still "doesn't trust AI", but all her verification almost 100% matched Claude's conclusions

She's right not to trust it for something like this. The "almost 100%" is the problem (also consider that you're sending personal data to anthropic without permission) especially for something like this where it might mean discarding someone's resume, which is something that could have a significant impact on a person's life.

What human has better than “almost 100%” on a dull task they have to grind at for 3 days?

Humans are terrible at that kind of long term focus, make clerical errors, etc.