Remix.run Logo
Stop using natural language interfaces(tidepool.leaflet.pub)
52 points by steveklabnik 5 hours ago | 10 comments
your_friend 13 minutes ago | parent | next [-]

I think text interface sucks, but at the same time I like how Claude code solve that with questionnaires, I think that’s the most elegant solution to get a lot of valuable context from users in a fast way

rock_artist 35 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

The post suggests how to optimize the LLM text with UI elements that reduce the usage of pure/direct prompts.

And that’s perfectly fine.

Though the title in that sense is more of a click-bait.

renegade-otter 36 minutes ago | parent | prev | next [-]

My boss used to say: "there is an easy way and there is the cool way".

We no longer have StackOverflow. We no longer have Google, effectively.

I used to be able to copy pasta code with incredible speed - now all of that is gone.

Chatbots is all we have. And they are not that bad at search, with no sponsored results to weed through. For now.

kami23 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Love this, this is what I have been envisioning as a LLM first OS! Feels like truly organic computing. Maybe Minority Report figured it out way back then.

The idea of having the elements anticipated and lowering the cognitive load of searching a giant drop down list scratches a good place in my brain. Instantly recognize it as such a better experience than what we have on the web.

I think something like this is the long term future for personal computing, maybe I'm way off, but this the type of computing I want to be doing, highly customized to my exact flow, highly malleable to improvement and feedback.

rurban an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Of course not. Users love the chatbot. It's fast and easier to use than manually searching for answers or sticking together reports and graphs.

There is no latency, because the inference is done locally. On a server at the customer with a big GPU

SoftTalker an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> just because we suddenly can doesn't mean we always should

Author should take his own advice.

legostormtroopr an hour ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Unless I am wildly misreading this, this is actually worse that both GUIs and LLMs combined.

LLMs offer a level of flexibility and non-determinism that allow them to adapt to different situations.

GUIs offer precision and predictability - they are the same every time. Which means people can learn them and navigate them quickly. If you've ever seen a bank teller or rental car agent navigate a GUI or TUI they tab through and type so quickly because they have expert familliarity.

But this - with a non-determinstic user interface generated by AI, every time a user engages with a UI its different. So they a more rigid UI but also a non-deterministic set of options every time. Which means instead of memorising what is in every drop down and tabbing through quickly, they need to re-learn the interface every time.

AlexCoventry 28 minutes ago | parent [-]

I don't think you have to use this if it's not working in your case. I think the idea is to try to anticipate the next few turns of the conversation, so you can pick the tree you want to go down in a fast way. If the prediction is accurate, I could see that being effective.

dhruv3006 3 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

This is something I agree with.Will be interesting to see if more and more people take this philosophy up.

gigatexal 40 minutes ago | parent | prev [-]

Yeah … no. It’s really nice interface. It’s here to stay.