He asked the models to fix the problem without commentary and then… praised the models that returned commentary. GPT-5 did exactly what he asked. It doesn’t matter if it’s right or not. It’s the essence of garbage in and garbage out.

▲

zeroonetwothree a day ago | parent [-]

If they are supposed to replace actual devs we would expect them to behave like actual devs and push back against impossible requests.

	▲	sosodev a day ago \| parent [-]
		Except it's not an impossible request. If my manager told me "fix this code with no questions asked" I would produce a similar result. If you want it to push back, you can just ask it to do that or at least not forbid it to. Unless you really want a model that doesn't follow instructions?