Author of the post here.

I appreciate the spirited debate and I agree with most of it - on both sides. It's a strange place to be where I think both arguments for and against this case make perfect sense. All I have to go on then is my personal experience, which is the only objective thing I've got. This entire profession feels stochastic these days.

A few points of clarification...

1. I don't speak for anyone but myself. I'm wrong at least half the time so you've been warned.

2. I didn't use any fancy workflows to build these things. Just used dictation to talk to GitHub Copilot in VS Code. There is a custom agent prompt toward the end of the post I used, but it's mostly to coerce Opus 4.5 into using subagents and context7 - the only MCP I used. There is no plan, implement - nothing like that. On occasion I would have it generate a plan or summary, but no fancy prompt needed to do that - just ask for it. The agent harness in VS Code for Opus 4.5 is remarkably good.

3. When I say AI is going to replace developers, I mean that in the sense that it will do what we are doing now. It already is for me. That said, I think there's a strong case that we will have more devs - not less. Think about it - if anyone with solid systems knowledge can build anything, the only way you can ship more differentiating features than me is to build more of them. That is going to take more people, not more agents. Agents can only scale as far as the humans who manage them.

New account because now you know who I am :)

I would be really interested to learn more behind the scenes of the iOS app process. Having tried Claude Code to develop an iOS app ~6 months ago, it was pretty painful to get it to make something that looked good and was functional.

Once Opus "finished", how did you validate and give it feedback it might not have access to (like iPhone simulator testing)?

What do you think about the market for custom apps? Like one app, one customer? You describe future businesses as having one app/service and using AI to add more features, but you did something very different for your wife with AI and it sounds like it added a lot of value.