Remix.run Logo
xp84 2 days ago

no, it's not, those things are illegal but cars and trains are not illegal even though you can use them to run over people. Knives, same thing. Alcohol is not illegal even though you can use them to get people too drunk to resist you.

Criminalizing everything that could be used to do bad things is an extreme position. Instead of jumping right to "ban it" you should probably first have a discussion where you consider whether (A) that ban will make any difference to its availability to most people who are criminally-minded anyway and (B) whether it has positive benefits to the law-abiding.

ehnto 2 days ago | parent | next [-]

And what legitimate purpose are we balancing against the negative purposes in this circumstance?

potato3732842 2 days ago | parent [-]

I don't think there's a legitimate purpose for this. I do think no legislature is capable of outlawing this in a way that's both enforceable with some degree of impartiality (i.e. does not provide plausible deniability for a prosecutor to drag a legitimate service through a courtroom for political reasons) and incurs acceptable collateral damages (e.g. doesn't outlaw unrelated stuff that's fine).

motbus3 2 days ago | parent | prev [-]

On most sane societies guns are illegal, drugs are illegal and blackmailing is illegal