That's not how you're supposed to handle this kind of errors (according to .NET designers) - there's 2 kinds of errors in concept, everyday errors that are to be expected, such as a dictionary not containing a key, or in this case, a user supplying a badly formatted integer. For this you have the Try.. methods with TryGetValue, TryParse etc.

Go for example, allows for multiple return values, so it allows more elegant handling of this exact cass.

Then there's the serious kind of error, when something you didn't expect goes wrong. That's what exceptions are for. If this distinction is followed, then you don't want to handle specific exceptions (with very few notable distinctions, like TaskCanceledException), you just either pick a recoverable function scope (like a HTTP handler), and let the exception bubble to its top, at which point you report an error to the user, and log what happened.

If such a thing is not possible, just let the program crash.