The admiration some readers have for Jay Gatsby (even though he’s meant to be a tragic figure) reminds me of how some currently view the character of Patrick Bateman from American Psycho as aspirational (minus the murder). I think America values success and beauty so dearly that it can override better judgement in cases.

They’re completely different characters and their qualities are completely different. You can easily admire tragic figures, as well.

As whole essay could be written about how this comparison misunderstands The Great Gatsby.