You are both correct and the article discusses it accurately:

> Then you have 2048 bytes of user data, scrambled for the reasons mentioned before. The best way to look at the sector as a whole is to think of each sector as 12 “rows” consisting of 172 bytes each. After each 172-byte row is 10 bytes of ECC data called Parity Inner (PI), which is based on Reed-Solomon and applied to both the header and scrambled user data per row within the sector itself. Then, after the user data and parity inner data, is the 4-byte EDC, which is calculated over the unscrambled user data only. Then, finally, Parity Outer (PO) is another form of ECC that is applied by “column” that spans over an entire block of multiple sectors stacked horizontally, or in other words, a group of 16 sectors. Altogether, this adds up to 2366 bytes of recorded sector data.