Remix.run Logo
3eb7988a1663 12 hours ago

You are already paying for several national lab HPC centers. These are used for government/university research - no idea if commercial interests can rent time on them. The big ones are running weather, astronomy simulations, nuclear explosions, biological sequencing, and so on.

fdr 11 hours ago | parent | next [-]

The biggest run classified nuclear stockpile loads, at least in the US. They cost about half a billion apiece. And are 30 (carefully cooled and cabled) megawatts. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/El_Capitan_(supercomputer)

No chance they're going to take risks to share that hardware with anyone given what it does.

The scaled down version of El Capitan is used for non-classified workloads, some of which are proprietary, like drug simulation. It is called Tuolumne. Not long ago, it was nevertheless still a top ten supercomputer.

Like OP, I also don't see why a government supercomputer does it better than hyperscalers, coreweave, neoclouds, et al, who have put in a ton of capital as even compared to government. For loads where institutional continuity is extremely important, like weather -- and maybe one day, a public LLM model or three -- maybe. But we're not there yet, and there's so much competition in LLM infrastructure that it's quite likely some of these entrants will be bag holders, not a world of juicy margins at all...rather, playing chicken with negative gross margins.

serf 11 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

>The big ones are running weather, astronomy simulations, nuclear explosions, biological sequencing, and so on.

these things constitute public goods that benefit the individual regardless of participation.

nine_k 11 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Many more people materially benefit from e.g. good weather forecasts than form video slop generation.