Remix.run Logo
bborud 8 hours ago

I agree global vs local edits as a discriminator, but there is a bit of a sliding scale here. For instance when you edit a photo of something that is lit by multiple light sources that have different color temperatures. The photo will produce a representation that shows more dramatic differences than you might be aware of when you look at the same scene. So when editing a photo, you may apply some processing to different areas to nudge the colors closer to how you’d “see” them.

Ditto for black and white photos. Your visual perception has pretty high dynamic range. Not least because your eyes move and your brain creates a representation that gives you the illusion of higher dynamic range than what your eyes can actually deliver. So when you want to represent it using a technology that can only give you a fraction of the dynamic range you (or your camera) can see, you sometimes make local’ish edits (eg create a mask with brush or gradients to lighten or darken regions)

Ansel Adams did a lot of dodging and burning in his prints. Some of the more famous ones are very obvious in terms of having been “processed” during the exposure of the print.

I see this as overcoming the limitations in conveying what your eyes/brain will see when using the limited capabilities of camera/screen/print. It is local’ish edits, but the intent isn’t so much to deceive as it is to nudge information into a range where it can be seen/understood.