Remix.run Logo
nephihaha 11 hours ago

It is up to those people to acquire German or French or whatever. I lived in Germany for a short while. I agree with "In Deutschland muss man Deutsch sprechen" and made an effort to do so, even though my German was far from perfect. Nothing racist about that at all. When I visited Japan decades ago, I made an effort to pick up enough Japanese to be able to function.

If you go to a country which does not speak your language and you expect everyone to know yours, then that is a colonial mentality.

stoneforger 11 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Lingua Franca predates colonialism. Latin predates Lingua Franca, although one can argue Latin was forced down due to the Roman Empire's extensive reach and size. Ancient Greek also served a similar role. One doesn't need to learn each others language as long as they all know one common language. One could argue for Esperanto, or a purely symbolic language like traffic icons, but you need to learn that one too. So it makes more sense to use a fit for purpose language for travel that has no ambiguities. You can even create a graph that can be queried. There's all sorts of ways to solve this with as little pain as possible as long as you care to. And wanting people to just learn the local language to traverse a transport network is chauvinism.

nephihaha 7 hours ago | parent [-]

The term "lingua franca" comes out of the Holy Roman Empire and Norman expansion, and later French imperialism, which gave it high status.

But I have long wondered whether many European languages will end up in the same state as Welsh or Basque or Sorbian. Icelandic is already much of the way there. Will Dutch and even German go the same way?

It is chauvinistic and colonial-minded to expect everyone to speak your language in their country. Not to mention arrogant.

umanwizard 9 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

If you visited Japan as a tourist, I believe you learned enough to say hello, ask someone where your hotel is, and so on. I don’t for a second believe you learned enough to understand arbitrary train network change announcements. Unless you spend years studying the language before visiting any country as a tourist, which would be absurd.

nephihaha 7 hours ago | parent [-]

No, I didn't learn vast amounts of Japanese, but I did learn phrases and the kanji for various destinations. It sped things up. I did not stand around and speak English to people slowly and expect them all to understand.