Remix.run Logo
f1shy 16 hours ago

> The human eye is most sensitive to green light,

This argument is very confusing: if is most sensitive, less intensity/area should be necessary, not more.

Lvl999Noob 15 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Since the human eye is most sensitive to green, it will find errors in the green channel much easier than the others. This is why you need _more_ green data.

afiori 8 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Because that reasoning applies to binary signals, where the sensibility is about detection, in the case of our eyes sensibility means that we can detect many more distinct values let's say we can see N distinct luminosity levels of monochrome green light but only N*k or N^k distinct levels of blue light.

So to describe/reproduce what our eyes see you need more detection range in the green spectrum

gudzpoz 15 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Note that there are two measurement systems involved: first the camera, and then the human eyes. Your reasoning could be correct if there were only one: "the sensor is most sensitive to green light, so less sensor area is needed".

But it is not the case, we are first measuring with cameras, and then presenting the image to human eyes. Being more sensitive to a colour means that the same measurement error will lead to more observable artifacts. So to maximize visual authenticity, the best we can do is to make our cameras as sensitive to green light (relatively) as human eyes.

f1shy 6 hours ago | parent [-]

Oh you are right! I’m so dumb! Of course it is the camera. To have the camera have the same sensitivity, we need more green pixels! I had my neurons off. Thanks.

matsemann 11 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Yeah, was thinking the same. If we're more sensitive, why do we need double sensors? Just have 1:1:1, and we would anyways see more of the green? Won't it be too much if we do 1:2:1, when we're already more perceptible to green?

seba_dos1 7 hours ago | parent [-]

With 1:1:1 the matrix isn't square, and if you have to double one of the channels for practical purposes then the green one is the obvious pick as it's the most beneficial in increasing the image quality cause it's increasing the spatial resolution where our eyes can actually notice it.

Grab a random photo and blur its blue channel out a bit. You probably won't notice much difference aside of some slight discoloration. Then try the same with the green channel.