new | show | ask | jobs Github

risyachka 2 hours ago

>> For anyone looking to study Russian...

just study some other language that has some culture to it or can be useful.

Don't waste your time on russian

▲

mlrtime an hour ago | parent | next [-]

Can you just tell us your biases instead of making us guess?

Why doesn't Russian have culture, why is it not useful?

	▲	risyachka an hour ago \| parent [-]
		Regarding culture I was unfortunate I had to briefly learn some russian history. And why not useful? Kinda obvious if you studied russia even basic via wikipedia. Russia has absolutely nothing to offer - neither to individuals nor to the world in general. The only thing they ever did are wars. And all inventions etc they copy/steal or those very few are result of research into weapons. And the people is another story. Go to russia and see for yourslft. Why would one learn language of this country if you can learn spanish/portuguese etc and get actual value from it or at least be able to communicate with nice people with come culture

▲

reorder9695 2 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

You're honestly saying that Russia of all places has no history or culture?

▲

Yizahi 2 hours ago | parent [-]

She's saying that Ruzzian history and culture doesn't deserve neither recognition nor effort to learn them, at this period of time. It's fine if a person is already partially or fully embedded in those, you can't "unlearn" stuff. But I'm personally baffled at the people on reddit book subs who are clearly westerners and writing that they are actively trying to learn Ruzzian to read some Tolstoevsky. Yeah, I'm impressed, twice, both at the spectacularly low reward/effort ratio and the sheer tone deafness of it all. In 2025. Or 2024. Or 2023. Etc.

▲

mlrtime an hour ago | parent [-]

So because of a war they shouldn't learn Russian, and why do you type it as "Ruzzian"?

The effort people put into criticizing how others spend their time is baffling, especially on HN.

▲

risyachka an hour ago | parent | next [-]

Yup.

Not because of war. Because all russia has to offer this world is destruction and learning russian is the biggest waste of time one can come up with.

Only if you don't know any russians you may think "I may communicate with them". When time comes and you meet more than 1 random example of them - you will not want to speak with them ever again.

These are facts from big numbers of people who actually konw them.

If you think "but i know a guy at work at my US company he is from russia" - mate, he is nothing like russians, and he also hides like 90% of his true self.

	▲	ramonga 7 minutes ago \| parent \| next [-]
		russian is also natively spoken in Belarus, Ukraine & many ethnics minorities inside russian federation.
	▲	mlrtime an hour ago \| parent \| prev \| next [-]
		I'm teaching my son Russian and English now as well as the rich culture. I can also teach him to think critically and NOT support war. I'm sorry your experience has been so one sided, we all have different persepctives.
	▲	Alex2037 an hour ago \| parent \| prev [-]
		it is delightfully damning that you people say such things out loud :)

▲

fractallyte 23 minutes ago | parent | prev [-]

russians (this time spelt with a lowercase 'r') have forfeited their right to exist as a nation.

Consistently throughout history, they have invaded, colonized, and genocided their neighbors.

They are doing it now, while the whole world watches. If anything, their brazenness is increasing - because they know there will never be any punishment.

When people wonder how Germans allowed their country to tip over into Nazism, modern russia is a perfect reenactment of that: we can see it happening, in real time.

And it's a blazing indictment that the rest of our "civilized" world is doing the absolute minimum to prevent history from repeating itself. Utterly SHAMEFUL.