new | show | ask | jobs Github

bhhaskin 4 hours ago

This sounds great on paper, but what happens when the OS isn't working for the user like Windows?

▲

hamandcheese 4 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Switch OS.

▲

iwontberude 4 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Windows is dead

▲

pixl97 4 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

I mean this was an app for accessing WhatsApp data, you would approve it and go on... the problem is with it sending data off to a 3rd party.

▲

bhhaskin 3 hours ago | parent [-]

I think you miss understood. If the OS becomes the arbiter of what can and cannot be accessed; it's a slippery slope to the OS becoming a walled garden that only approved apps and developers are allowed to operate. Of course that is a pretty large generalization, but we already see it with mobile devices and are starting to see it with windows and Mac OS.

I don't think we should be handing more power to OS makers and away from users. There has to be a middle ground between wall gardens and open systems. It would be much better for node & npm to come up with a solution than locking down access.

	▲	whstl 3 hours ago \| parent [-]
		The arbiter of what can be accessed should be the user, and always the user. The OS should be merely the enforcer. Currently OSs are a free-for-all, where the user must blindly trust third-party apps, or they enforce it clumsily like in macOS. This was fine in 1980 but isn't anymore.