The problem with this article is that GraphQL has become much more an enterprise solution over the last few years than a non enterprise one. Even though the general public opinion of X and HN seems to be that GraphQL has negative ROI, it's actually growing strongly in the enterprise API management segment.

GraphQL, in combination with GraphQL has become the new standard for orchestrating Microservices APIs and the development of AI and LLMs gives it even another push as MCP is just another BFF and that's the sweet spot of GraphQL.

Side note, I'm not even defending GraphQL here, it's just about facts if we're looking at who's using and adopting GraphQL. If you look around, from Meta to Airbnb, Uber, Reddit or Booking.com, Atlassian or Monday, GitHub or Gitlab, all these services use GraphQL successfully and these days, banks are adopting it to modernize API access to their Mainframe, SOAP and proprietary RPC APIs.

How do I know you might say? I'm working with WunderGraph (https://wundergraph.com/), one of the most innovative vendors in the market and we're talking to enterprise every day. We've just came home from API days Paris and besides AI and LLMs, everyone in the enterprise is talking about API design, governance and collaboration, which is where GraphQL Federation is very strong and the ecosystem is very mature.

Posts like this are super harmful for the API ecosystem because they come from inexperience and lack of knowledge.

GraphQL can solve over fetching but that's not the reason why enterprises adopt it. GraphQL Federation solves a people problem, not a technical one. It helps orgs scale and govern APIs across a large number of teams and services.

Just recently there was a post here on HN about the problems with dependencies between Microservices, a problem that GraphQL Federation solves very elegantly with the @requires directive.

One thing I've learned over the years is that people who complain about GraphQL are typically not working in the enterprise, and those who use the query language successfully don't usually post on social media about it. It's a tool in the API tool belt besides others like Open API and Kafka. Just go to an API conference and ask what people use.