Remix.run Logo
keeda 4 days ago

I think you would be surprised by how much these AIs can "fill in the blanks" based on the surrounding code and high-level context! Here is an example I posted a few months ago (which is coincidentally, related to the reply I just gave the sibling comment): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=44892576

Look at the length of my prompt and the length of the code. And that's not even including the tests I had it generate. It made all the right assumptions, including specifying tunable optional parameters set to reasonable defaults and (redacted) integrating with some proprietary functions at the right places. It's like it read my mind!

Would you really think writing all that code by hand would have been comparable to writing the prompt?

skydhash 3 days ago | parent [-]

I’m not surprised. It would be like being suprised by the favt that computers can generate a human portrait (which has been been a thing before LLMs), but people are still using 3d software because while it takes more time, they have more control over the final result.

keeda 3 days ago | parent [-]

We still have complete control over the code, because after the AI generates it, it's right there to tweak as we want!

But the point is, there were no assumptions or tooling or bad designs that had to be fought. Just an informal, high-level prompt that generated the exact code I wanted in a fraction of the time. At least to me that was pretty surprising -- even if it'd become routine for a while by then -- because I'd expect that level of wavelength-match between colleagues who had been working on the same team for a while.