Remix.run Logo
WhyNotHugo 3 days ago

I've not seen any mention of how this affect families.

A lot of my family growing up lived in different cities. We kept in touch via social media. PSTN was expensive and impractical. Postal mail was obviously less practical.

Does this new ban move kids to using email to keep in touch with friends and family? Are they now completely isolated from the rest of the world?

brailsafe 3 days ago | parent [-]

> Does this new ban move kids to using email to keep in touch with friends and family?

You had social media but no ability to send DMs?

In an attempt to not deliberately misinterpret you, next to zero of my current ability to keep in touch with anyone in my life via the internet, distant or otherwise, depends on social media, so forgive me if this seems like a strange take. Kids need access to YouTube in order to talk to their family?

> Are they now completely isolated from the rest of the world?

It's only in extremely recent history that anyone, especially kids, had access to the rest of the world in any meaningful way, or at the resolution available now. I don't think it's remotely healthy for adults to concern themselves with the hourly regional issues wherever they're occuring in the world; it costs society a great deal more than it earns imo (but it's very profitable for the companies on this list)

WhyNotHugo 2 days ago | parent [-]

> In an attempt to not deliberately misinterpret you, […] Kids need access to YouTube in order to talk to their family?

Your attempt has failed; obviously I’m not taking about YouTube, but about things like WhatsApp, Telegram, WeChat, Instagram, and other social media which families actually use to talk to each other on a dialy basis.

Perhaps you don’t use these, but most of the world population uses some of these (or something similar) to keep in touch with family and friends.

Heck, even when I was a teen (before smartphones) I kept in touch with friends over social media. We’d even organise meeting up through it.

BlueTemplar 2 days ago | parent | next [-]

Out of all of those, only Instagram is on the list (or I have heard has complied despite not being on it).

You seem to be confusing messaging software and social media ?

Do (the others than Instagram) have an algorithmic feed, or (effectively) do not work without making an account ?

I guess that there's also Discord (that isn't on the list but has still complied) that is in an awkward in-between ?

(IMHO both Instagram and Discord ought to be banned anyway, for everyone, because they're deep web platforms that are owned by Meta/Tencent, and are therefore a threat to the open web and liberal democracy.)

brailsafe 2 days ago | parent | prev [-]

Seems like you're conflating chat with social media. If we throw out the posts and dopamine abuse I don't think we lose much.