Remix.run Logo
jandrese 2 days ago

Ada would never have been cool.

Ironically I remember one of the complaints was it took a long time for the compilers to stabilize. They were such complex beasts with a small userbase so you had smallish companies trying to develop a tremendously complex compiler for a small crowd of government contractors, a perfect recipe for expensive software.

I think maybe they were just a little ahead of their time on getting a good open source compiler. The Rust project shows that it is possible now, but back in the 80s and 90s with only the very early forms of the Internet I don't think the world was ready.

skepti3 2 days ago | parent [-]

Out of curiosity:

1: If you had to guess, how high is the level of complexity of rustc?

2: How do you think gccrs will fare?

3: Do you like or dislike the Rust specification that originated from Ferrocene?

4: Is it important for a systems language to have more than one full compiler for it?

jandrese 2 days ago | parent [-]

Given how much memory and CPU time is burned compiling Rust projects I'm guessing it is pretty complex.

I'm not deep enough into the Rust ecosystem to have solid opinions on the rest of that, but I know from the specification alone that it has a lot of work to do every time you execute rustc. I would hope that the strict implementation would reduce the number of edge cases the compiler has to deal with, but the sheer volume of the specification works against efforts to simplify.