Remix.run Logo
knowitnone3 10 hours ago

how broad? you're suggesting give them everything while expecting nothing? I'll be the first in line for my new car.

SequoiaHope 42 minutes ago | parent [-]

I intentionally described policies which are already common practice in most European countries, nothing extravagant. Yes there is some cost but the alternative is deep human suffering which is otherwise avoidable.

But this isn’t really “giving them” anything. It’s giving ourselves safety and security.

It wouldn’t make sense to give you a car. We would give you a working train system instead. Again this is common in Europe and Asia. Indeed every person is “given” access to a high quality transit network with affordable tickets.

To be clear, I personally am an anarcho communist. I think we would be better off if we organized to ensure every person has their basic needs met by the established wealth of society. That isn’t all that dramatic - making sure everyone can ride high quality trains and get medical care when they need it are common in most countries for example.

For housing, I really like the Vienna model:

https://socialhousing.wien/policy/the-vienna-model

For food, follow the Sikhs:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46126736

Consider the Linux ecosystem. “Give them everything and expect nothing” works fine despite the great effort which goes in to building and maintaining that system. We can study the economics of this and build more systems like that.