Remix.run Logo
jchw 4 hours ago

Yes! This sounds like a great idea to me. It does have some trade-offs, but I think we would've been better off with this than ever having put queries in the URL in the first place. Rather, if it made enough sense to have some data in the URL itself, it would be better if it could actually be in the path, to distinguish it as a distinct resource. I think there are many reasons why this didn't work out that way but I also think those reasons are mostly historical. I would prefer things like /map/<lat>/<long>/, for example. I don't want to go as far as to say that query parameters were entirely a mistake, but there's nothing they do that couldn't be done otherwise, they just offer a convenient place to delineate unstructured data in a URL that you could then copy around. Sometimes moving that to the path would be awkward (unstructured path elements does exist on the web, but it's weird to do) but often times it would just be better to not have it at all. Don't need UTM codes in my URLs in the first place, and I don't think every single parameter on the page should be in the URL. (If you really wanted to pass someone a saved search full of complex queries, it would be less cumbersome to have a specific URL for saved searches anyhow, in my opinion.)

Obviously query parameters are not going anywhere, but if this achieves enough adoption there is a future down the road where we can stop using POST for any query that wants a payload, without needing to change every single HTTP client in the world. (Many of them can already understand custom methods and treat them basically like posts.)

stephenr 3 hours ago | parent [-]

> I would prefer things like /map/<lat>/<long>/, for example.

PathInfo is a thing you can absolutely use.

jchw an hour ago | parent [-]

Most web application servers have already equipped to be able to easily parse parameters out of the URL path for many years, of course, it's definitely nothing new, it's just that historically, people reached for URL query parameters for this sort of thing. After all, making a request with query parameters is basically built into the browser; you can do it with <form> and anchor links with no JS needed.

Presumably, because of that, many pages will continue to use query parameters for the foreseeable future. I think that's fine, but at least for APIs, the QUERY method could eventually be a very nice thing to have.