Remix.run Logo
skybrian 13 hours ago

Apparently Microsoft tried it and it worked, but they shelved it?

https://www.tomshardware.com/desktops/servers/microsoft-shel...

creatonez 7 hours ago | parent [-]

It didn't work, it was an utterly terrible idea and they are almost certainly lying about the sentiment that it "worked". No ability to perform maintenance is a complete nonstarter. Communications and power is a nightmare to get right. The thermal management story sucks - just because you have metal touching water doesn't mean you have effective radiation of heat. Actually scaling it up is nearly impossible because you need thicker and more expensive vessels the bigger it gets. The problems go on and on.

skybrian 6 hours ago | parent [-]

Presumably it didn't work well or they wouldn't have shelved it. But do you actually know about what happened or is this all based on your priors?

wmf 4 hours ago | parent [-]

I don't think MS ever revealed enough information to answer that. For example, I haven't seen any explanation of how heat is transferred from the servers to the skin of the container. I can guess how they did it but I don't want to make any judgement based on guesses.