That's because you have incorrectly inferred from our statements saying that Core should get the data, or rather that the data should be publicly archived, as us saying that Core has a right to the data. You are again constructing a strawman to argue against.

EDIT: Also, if Rebble scraping it from Pebble isn't theft, then neither would Core scraping it from Rebble. Problem solved.

Only Pebble can make the claim that Rebble stole from Pebble, or that Pebble was materially damaged by it.

Rebble did not have any agreement with Pebble the way they did with Core.