You know, this would be a fantastic time for Google to get their sandbox in order. If we need to do it like this, go ahead and create a secondary user, call it sandbox and let me install all my wild and unapproved apps there. SecureNet can automatically fail in Sandbox.

But I don't think they're going to do that, ultimately users who actually care about this are an absolute tiny percentage of the market.

And weirdos like us can always just import a Chinese phone that doesn't have mandatory Google verification crap.

▲

cesarb 9 days ago | parent | next [-]

> And weirdos like us can always just import a Chinese phone that doesn't have mandatory Google verification crap.

No, we can't. One of the first countries with that mandatory Google verification is Brazil, and we can't import phones which are not certified by ANATEL, they will be rejected by customs in transit.

▲

lisdexan 9 days ago | parent | next [-]

I knew Brazil was kinda weird with tech import taxes but I didn't know they banned non-certified phones, jezz. Here in Chile they get disconnected from the cell towers after 30 days, but you just need register it^.

Do you know if the Brazilian gov or regulators asked for this first from Google or something?

^: It's less spooky than it sounds, any phone in Chile needs to be compatible with the natural disaster alert system.

	▲	marcosdumay 9 days ago \| parent [-]
		Yes, Brazil doesn't allow the commerce of uncertified radio transmitters. It has been like that for close to a century. If you are asking why the change is happening in Brazil first, the banks cartel met with google and decided to rely on that, for security.

▲

marcosdumay 9 days ago | parent | prev [-]

With elections coming next year, and this being practically a "law" created in partnership with the banks cartel, this may be the time to make some noise about the change.

▲

Manuel_D 9 days ago | parent | prev | next [-]

But the purpose of prohibiting sideloading isn't security. It's preventing of apps like NewPipe and Vanced.

▲

Brian_K_White 9 days ago | parent | prev | next [-]

But what would be the point when no one would bother writing an app for such a small user base?

▲

999900000999 9 days ago | parent | next [-]

So I can test my own apps on my own devices, or upload them to itch for other weird people.

I don't feel like giving Google a large amount of my personal information just so I can distribute free games. Why do they need a copy of my lease ?

▲

t_mahmood 9 days ago | parent [-]

The point parent is making, if Google makes it so difficult sharing the software with other people, who is going to make those itch-the-scratch software going through so much trouble?

We would miss out a lot of creative people making software.

	▲	Brian_K_White 9 days ago \| parent [-]
		Correct. What I am saying is: There is still a few points of course like being able to modify the base system. Just being able to say, kill the built in facebook is a quality of life improvement. But it just feels like the benefits of a self owned phone os are going away even when you have it, because everything else changes around it and out from under it, so you don't get the functional benefit from it any more even when you have it. You give up the use of things like tap to pay (would have been nice a couple times when I forgot my wallet) and drm content, hell, I can't use the stupid LG app that controls an air conditioner, and (increasingly) don't get something else important in return. Today, there is still some benefit, because this latest change is only just now happening. I can use say, open source password manager and totp apps instead of google authenticator, and can use a pandora client that Pandora absolutely does not approve of, because the author doesn't need anyone's approval to produce the app and there is no choke point that Pandora can petition to block it. Hell why am I even talking about Pandora instead of Youtube and Newpipe? In what universe does Google EVER ratify the developer of Newpipe? (Wait, for that matter, what developer? what if there's an ever-changing fuzzy cloud of 20?) Or full-fat ublock origin...or countless other things whos sole purpose and value is to thwart some will of Googles? Or like the game emulator apps that Nintendo shuts down so aggressively, etc. Those ICE tracking or merely documenting apps. Countless... Will those various authors still bother putting in the time and effort it takes to make these apps so good when only about 18 people will be able to use them? I imported a Sony phone to the US because they don't sell it here, and no one else sells a current flagship with a headphone jack and removable sd card and high end cameras. I successfully found and imported the phone, and got it working on a US carrier. Yay me. It's even rootable! Yay me. Yet I still can't run Lineage on it, because there is probably not a dozen other people like me to be an audience for Lineage on this hardware, and it's too much work to do for no audience. The fact that today most phones are unrootable means that even if you somehow get around that, you still don't get the benefit because you're such a small audience that no one is producing say LineageOS for example for you. My individual success bucking the system still did not result in me getting what I want.

▲

noitpmeder 9 days ago | parent | prev [-]

Maybe so I can develop a service without forking over profit to a company that deserves none of it.

▲

lisdexan 9 days ago | parent | prev | next [-]

I haven't tested it myself, but as far as I know you can run ADB in the phone itself via Termux. Perhaps it's possible to make a wrapper that install apps from F-Droid with ADB? It would mean that you would only need to be tethered to the your PC once.

Obviously they'll eventually remove this because Google is hostile to things like ReVanced / some spook wants this power.

▲

sipofwater 9 days ago | parent | next [-]

ADB using two Android smartphones and Termux (https://github.com/termux/termux-app):

* Search for "Smartphone-1 to Smartphone-2" "adb tcpip 5555" in "Motorola moto g play 2024 smartphone, Termux, termux-usb, usbredirect, QEMU running under Termux, and Alpine Linux: Disks with Globally Unique Identifier (GUID) Partition Table (GPT) partitioning": https://old.reddit.com/r/MotoG/comments/1j2g5gz/motorola_mot... (old.reddit.com/r/MotoG/comments/1j2g5gz/motorola_moto_g_play_2024_smartphone_termux/)

* Search for "termux-adb" in "Motorola moto g play 2024 Smartphone, Android 14 Operating System, Termux, And cryptsetup: Linux Unified Key Setup (LUKS) Encryption/Decryption And The ext4 Filesystem Without Using root Access, Without Using proot-distro, And Without Using QEMU": https://old.reddit.com/r/MotoG/comments/1jkl0f8/motorola_mot... (old.reddit.com/r/MotoG/comments/1jkl0f8/motorola_moto_g_play_2024_smartphone_android_14/)

	▲	lisdexan 9 days ago \| parent [-]
		It's not necessary to use two phones, see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45740033

▲

Groxx 9 days ago | parent | prev [-]

AFAICT it only works on non-rooted devices when used over USB to access another device, because without root it has no access to the adb server on the phone running termux.

I'm definitely not 100% sure about that though, so someone please correct me if not.

▲

lisdexan 9 days ago | parent [-]

Just tested⁰, it works with WiFi ADB but it has some limitations.

- The pairing process is kinda awkward, you need to split screen Termux and the Wireless debugging submenu, if you change windows the pairing IP and code are changed.

- The pair survives a reboot and WiFi change. You can disable the 7day revocation, so the pairing process is a one time thing.

- After a pair you still need to connect (adb connect localhost:port) and the port changes after a WiFi change or disconnect. I searched for solutions and apparently it's simple as running nmap twice¹

- It obviously doesn't work without a WiFi connection (unless is there some dark magic to connect your phone to its own hotspot).

So a wrapper seems viable if you are ok only installing apps on trusted networks.

[0]: I'm on GrapheneOS but I believe the dev menu is the same.

[1]: https://www.reddit.com/r/tasker/comments/1dqm8tq/project_sim...

	▲	lisdexan 9 days ago \| parent \| next [-]
		More googling, Shizuku² does this already in a polished way and exposes an API for other apps. Some related-ish apps are SAI³ (for installing split apks) and Canta⁴ (removing system apps). EDIT: Even more googling, the whole setup already exists in Obtainium (i.e. F-Droid but with Github Releases) apparently so apps show up as being installed via Play Store and subsequently be usable in Android Auto⁵. So hypothetically you can install stuff day one on a stock phone after this atrocity is turned on. [2]: https://shizuku.rikka.app/ [3]: https://f-droid.org/en/packages/com.aefyr.sai.fdroid/ [4]: https://f-droid.org/en/packages/io.github.samolego.canta/ [5]: https://github.com/ImranR98/Obtainium/issues/1859
	▲	Groxx 9 days ago \| parent \| prev [-]
		wifi adb is a clever workaround, lol. I haven't seen that before, but it does kinda make sense. I've used SAI before (though it has been having lots more problems in the past year or three), but haven't seen Shizuku. thank you for the testing and details!

▲

palata 9 days ago | parent | prev [-]

Or just install an alternative AOSP-based OS. Ironically one of the best phones for that is the Pixel, because it runs GrapheneOS.