Remix.run Logo
tsimionescu 3 hours ago

As far as I can see, Searle rejects the whole concept, and claims that by construction, it is obvious that the Chinese room doesn't understand Chinese in the same way that a speaker does, regardless of how well it can mimic Chinese speech.

netdevphoenix 2 hours ago | parent [-]

> claims that by construction, it is obvious that

Sounds like circular logic to me unless you make that assumption explicit

tsimionescu 2 hours ago | parent [-]

Yes, that's what I'm "accusing" him of. I'm sure his defenders view his argument differently.