Meanwhile I've mixed a song of mine down on a Tascam 688 8-track tape recorder. I have a big smile on my face because I find this very enjoyable. The haptics, the sound and my hand-crafted product. A piece of art made by a human. No AI will replace this for me.

▲

moritzwarhier 4 hours ago | parent [-]

I'm pretty sure your creation will be more interesting than any AI-generated "art".

Suno can create catchy songs and succeed in matching genre expectations / cliches.

I've been in phases where I had output I generated with it playing in my head constantly (due to repeated listening).

The output was catchy.

Then tried to generate interesting music, failed spectacularly.

And I, among other stuff, enjoy a lot of music that people consider formulaic, abstract or straight-up boring.

What's missing in AI "art" is intent and well... creativity.

I think it will have a disrupting influence on commercial pop culture, no question.

I also wouldn't claim to be able to classify correctly whether something is AI output.

But art is something entirely different.

	▲	Rochus 3 hours ago \| parent [-]
		> Then tried to generate interesting music, failed spectacularly. You can upload music and let suno arrange it in different styles. I'm a musician myself and am also interested in "interesting" music. I made experiments with my own music and was positively surprised by the "musicality" and creativity of the generated arrangements (https://rochus-keller.ch/?p=1350).