Remix.run Logo
landl0rd 2 days ago

- The AMA froze the number of med schools for decades even as residency availability increased.

- The majority of states still maintain "certificate of need" laws for new hospitals, ambulance providers, etc.

- The AMA holds a state-enforced monopoly over physicians.

- Many states still limit NPs/PAs, requiring physician supervision for things for which those people were trained.

- Lack of interstate reciprocity in licensing means mobility is constrained and supply can't follow demand.

- Costly medical equipment usually requires first-party repairs; mfgs claim a third-party modification (repair) constitutes remanufacturing under FDA regs.

- Stark law makes e.g. physician/hospital value-based care arrangements very hard. It's quite strict and everyone has to tiptoe around it a bit.

There's also the huge problem of malpractice insurance costs due to insane tort settlements. Awards need to be capped yesterday because it's too easy to talk a jury into bankrupting people over things that legitimately just sometimes happen.

I'm guessing others could give you an even better list. Some of those are a bigger deal than others but it's a huge issue. Insurance net margins just aren't high enough to blame it and drug costs aren't enough of our total healthcare spend to be at fault.

It comes down to humans being too expensive. There remain many areas of care where we can't cut man-hours down without sacrificing safety and quality. As such, we should reduce the insane byzantine co-ordination and compliance overhead.

dimal a day ago | parent [-]

Don’t forget that the AMA has a monopoly on billing codes. Medicare defines the billing value of every procedure as Relative Value Units (RVUs). Then Medicare defers to AMA’s guidance on what these values should be. Insurers default to RVUs x multiplier. So the AMA has the ability to set prices.

Oh, and patient value isn’t considered for these units. They are explicitly defined as input driven, so a procedure that is less costly to perform but has higher value to the patient will be billed at a lower value. Hospitals are incentivized to choose procedures that they can bill at a higher rate, and so because of these perverse incentives, they necessarily will ignore cheaper more effective treatments and choose the more expensive ones.

I’m a lefty, but the older I get the less I believe in the old New Deal style leftism I’ve been sold my whole life. As systems get more complex, they simply become a way to obfuscate oligarchic control.