Remix.run Logo
scott_w 2 days ago

Most of us aren't working for IBM building counting machines for the Nazis. We're talking about a situation where you think the company is making bad decisions, not one where you have an ideological disagreement.

If a manager isn't able to function in this environment then, frankly, I'm not sure that person is cut out to be a leader or manager...

oytis 2 days ago | parent [-]

It's not about functioning it's about integrity. As a manager you represent the company, and you represent the decisions. If you are not able to do it sincerely, you either do what the author describes or you go somewhere that aligns with you better. Good ones often have lower tolerance to bullshit and actually have choice, so they go. Sometimes you don't have a choice indeed.

scott_w 2 days ago | parent [-]

Are you seriously suggesting that you can only operate in an environment that you align with 100% of the time?

oytis 2 days ago | parent [-]

I think that you should work with companies you align well with. It is good for your well-being, your self-respect and eventually your career, but also it's good for the company too. Not sure what you find so controversial here

scott_w 2 days ago | parent [-]

> If you are not able to do it sincerely, you either do what the author describes or you go somewhere that aligns with you better.

This part. You seem under the impression that it’s impossible to do a good job unless you’re in total agreement with your management chain. That simply can’t happen 100% of the time, even in a job where you generally enjoy the work.

> It is good for your well-being, your self-respect

You seem to think one loses their self respect when they pick their battles and focus their energy on what they can control. I say that it’s better for your well being to not scream your life away into the void.

Look, there comes a time in every job where you need to move on because it’s not giving you what you want or need any more. I don’t judge that.

But part of management is knowing when you gotta suck it up, put on your big boy pants, and tell the team something you don’t agree with and that you need to make it work somehow. If you can’t handle that part of the job, then you’re really not cut out for management or leadership.