Remix.run Logo
LtWorf 11 hours ago

Like how americans are convinced they invented the telephone because the patent office said so?

itopaloglu83 an hour ago | parent | next [-]

Just like how the history is written by the victorious, every nation tends to accept certain truths as their truth.

exclusions apply, ask your doctor if the truth is right for you.

alanh 11 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Curious, I asked Grok:

> Is there controversy over the true inventor of the telephone?Yes, there is controversy over the true inventor of the telephone. While Alexander Graham Bell is widely credited, several inventors and researchers argue for recognition based on their contributions:

> Antonio Meucci: An Italian inventor who filed a patent caveat for a "voice communication apparatus" in 1871, five years before Bell's patent. Meucci's device, the "teletrofono," could transmit voice over a wire. Due to financial hardship, Meucci couldn't renew his caveat, and Bell was granted the patent in 1876. In 2002, the U.S. House of Representatives passed a resolution (H.Res. 269) recognizing Meucci's contributions, stating he demonstrated a working device earlier, though it didn't officially credit him as the inventor. Some still argue Meucci deserves primary credit.

> Elisha Gray: An American engineer who filed a patent caveat for a telephone-like device on the same day as Bell, February 14, 1876. Bell's patent was filed hours earlier, leading to disputes. Some claim Bell may have had access to Gray’s ideas through patent office connections, though no definitive evidence supports this. Gray later challenged Bell’s patent but lost in court.

> Philipp Reis: A German inventor who developed a device called the "Reis telephone" in 1861, capable of transmitting music and some speech. While it was less practical for clear voice communication, some argue it was a precursor to the telephone.

typpilol 11 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Ok I'm curious. Who's the real inventor

ghshephard 11 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Antonio Meucci invented the Teletrofono around 1849 and filed a patent for it in 1871. I know this mostly because it was a big deal in a Soprano's episode.

eru 11 hours ago | parent | prev | next [-]

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Timeline_of_the_telephone might be a good starting point.

alanh 11 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

See my reply to parent. Reply to sibling: Whoa, I've seen the Sopranos 3 times and never caught that reference.

LtWorf 7 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

And by the downvotes it seems they also get really touchy if it's pointed out…