Remix.run Logo
phoronixrly 5 days ago

Seems quite naive to think they'd be affected in any way by the tiny intersection of users that are both yt-dlp users and premium subscribers boycotting them...

renegat0x0 5 days ago | parent | next [-]

I think it is not about making a change, it is putting money where your mouth is.

To buy premium to support creators.

Once yt becomes hostile the deal between me and yt is off.

js8 4 days ago | parent | prev [-]

If every user of yt-dlp did as I do, then it would have exactly the effect that it needs to have. If yt-dlp is used by a small minority of users, why would Google be antagonistic to it? And if it's used by sizeable portion of users, then they would care.

majormajor 4 days ago | parent | next [-]

> If yt-dlp is used by a small minority of users, why would Google be antagonistic to it?

The concern is likely that if they let it become too easy the small minority becomes a large majority and the ad business becomes unsustainable.

Consider the ease and adoption of newsgroups in the early 90s vs Napster/Limewire later and the effect that had on revenues.

Mindwipe 4 days ago | parent | prev [-]

Primarily because they contractually promised the music industry they'd do everything they can to prevent tools that allow the downloading of copyrighted music from the service.