Remix.run Logo
manquer 5 days ago

> View counts are for monetization

Agree, however view counts, i.e. metrics tracked by YT, or by sponsors,creators in fancy dashboards isn't the view counter we are shown and nobody is questioning how those are implemented. The View Counter means very specific UI component in YT interface shown to regular users.

> view counter isn't for you

Disagree,

View counter is a important decision making input along with the thumbnail, title and duration of the video on if a user will click on the video to watch them.

It is in effect an advertisement for the video.

If that wasn't the case, then YouTube wouldn't be showing them in every list view and next to every thumbnail. When the numbers no longer represent what the users think they represent I would say it is not far from false advertising.

A fair amount of people on here and I have both YT Premium and also use some adblocker, should our views be counted or not according to this point of view? .

Braxton1980 5 days ago | parent [-]

I'm so glad other people here pay for premium because on Tiktok and Reddit a common joke is how few people pay for YT.

My Verizon cell phone plan offers it at a slightly discounted $10 a month. For a completely ad free (ads from Youtube) experience it's well worth it considering how many car and tech videos I watch.

It also offers a higher bitrate 1080p option on some videos which is a cherry on top.

xp84 5 days ago | parent [-]

Yeah it's absurd to me how much people bitch about YouTube advertising and don't pay. To me, either you don't watch enough YouTube for the complaints to be warranted, or you do watch a lot, and you're just torturing yourself to save $15 and blaming YouTube for your choice. It's like complaining about a Quarter Pounder "not coming with cheese" and constantly trying to steal cheese, when you could just pay the dollar and get cheese every time.

godshatter 3 days ago | parent | next [-]

I don't log in to YouTube because I don't want to participate in the Google ecosystem to that extent. That precludes paying for Premium. If they don't want me to watch videos, then they should gate them behind the login they already provide.

smnthermes 4 days ago | parent | prev [-]

Or they just don't want to support a dodgy advertising company.

xp84 4 days ago | parent [-]

→ "I don't want to support McDonald's" then don't go to McDonald's.