Remix.run Logo
stephencelis 3 days ago

I think you're missing the point. iOS 13 is not the value proposition of the library, it's simply one small feature of comparison of many and isn't highlighted beyond a simple mention. The library provides just as much value if you are starting a new app today and choose to target iOS 26+.

> And with Apple's history of source-breaking changes over major platform updates, plus given how even huge libraries/tools like Alamofire, Realm, RxSwift, Cocoapods eventually succumbed to oblivion, I can't think of why an Apple developer with any modicum of discernment would choose PointFree's tools over Apple's own--unless they are themselves caught by the allure of reinventing the wheel.

Isn't this just a blackpilled take in general? You're complaining that Apple software breaks, that other third party software is discontinued, and this somehow leads to the conclusion to avoid this library?

rTX5CMRXIfFG 3 days ago | parent [-]

If you think that through, the answer is: of course! Take for example the move from Swift 1 to 2 (an extreme example but illustrates the point).

If you used a third-party lib written in Swift 1 and you had to move to Swift 2 because the next version of iOS requires the latter. Then you’ll have to wait for the lib developer to publish a version of their third-party lib for Swift 2 before you can publish your app. That’s the same kind of risk that you’re exposed to with source-breaking changes.

Admittedly, source-breaking changes have gotten less frequent in Apple’s major tooling updates, but the right mindset when developing for walled gardens like Apple is that it will happen again.

jen20 3 days ago | parent [-]

You appear to have unwittingly made an argument for why to use this library over SwiftData - here you can control your own destiny instead of waiting for bugs to be fixed in the OS frameworks and customers to update.