Remix.run Logo
BurningFrog 3 days ago

Trains are great when going to tourist attractions, especially in the center of old cities.

When you live and work in a city, they're much less practical.

okanat 3 days ago | parent | next [-]

This is quite the "I have never lived anywhere else other than North America" take.

Rail and other public transport in pretty much everywhere in the world are designed to serve commute first, tourist stuff second or third.

Public transport isn't just having some trains, or having only trains between major cities. It is designing whole commute routes from various urban and suburban areas to workplace. There needs to be regional and suburban links that arrive to metro and tram stations. Metro and tram have to operate very frequently to handle commuters. The frequency of the trains should adapt to the commuters in the morning and evening. They need to be convenient, clean and safe too.

Cities around the world are also much better balanced than NA ones. The workplaces and living areas are almost always mixed rather than having a "downtown" area where every office worker travels to. My area has many buildings with a supermarket, apartments and small offices in the same building. There are two car factories in the city next to one of the biggest urban parks.

BurningFrog 2 days ago | parent [-]

I'm a European who has emigrated to the US, and knows both sides pretty well.

I agree that European trains work very well for commuting to and from the center of big cities. That's where the jobs and tourist attractions are.

But to go between arbitrary places A and B is usually quite painful. Often the best way is to go to the center, and then from there to your destination.

When I moved to the US and got a car, it was an unreal feeling! I could quickly travel anywhere at anytime!! Practically it felt like my comfortable travel radius increased from 10km to 50km.

mint5 3 days ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Is that why the trains and trams are crowded around commute? Because people find them impractical?

mjr00 3 days ago | parent | prev | next [-]

> Trains are great when going to tourist attractions, especially in the center of old cities. When you live and work in a city, they're much less practical.

This is the most "tell me you live in America without telling me you live in America" thing I've seen in a long time...

America basically the only place in the world where in its cities, trains and other public transport aren't a major part of people's lives. In other places (Seoul, Tokyo, many European cities, etc.), even people who own a car will sometimes commute via train due to the convenience.

panick21_ 3 days ago | parent | prev | next [-]

Come and live in Switzerland for a year and learn something.

krashidov 3 days ago | parent | prev [-]

Is this a serious comment lol