Then we agree. Piracy is a service issue.

There’s no controversy that copying data is easy. That’s obvious to everyone. What you have failed to articulate is why that’s relevant in a conversation on intellectual property rights.

> Then we agree. Piracy is a service issue.

I'd say piracy is best fought with better service but draconian laws and enforcement would also work.

> There’s no controversy that copying data is easy. That’s obvious to everyone. What you have failed to articulate is why that’s relevant in a conversation on intellectual property rights.

The fact that copying data is so easy means that any law trying to criminalize it is unjust by nature, that's my most important argument.