That is why you have capital gains, which is ~30% in France.

Investment income is flat taxed.

And inheritance taxes, which are very high in France.

If you want to increase taxes, consider taxing income more and capital gains at a progressive rate. Although I haven't seen good data on effects of say a 70% capital gain tax, might hurt th,e economy. I did some reading on this subject last month and the sweetspot was around 20% to 35% on that classification of income.

Do you want to take people's wealth and cap it? IE, nobody is allowed more than $5 million? What are you advocating for instead?

▲

verzali a day ago | parent [-]

I think the proposal from the left is a 2% wealth tax annually on wealth above €100 million. I suppose that is what they are referring to.

▲

bwb 11 hours ago | parent | next [-]

First, wealth tax doesn't work because it requires a ton of work to decide what constitutes "wealth," and then you have to carve out so much crap. The only wealth tax that currently works well is on real estate, as it doesn't move, and the state already taxes that.

For example, how do you tax a private business? In Spain, for example, it is a big carve-out, which leads to people never selling a company, which hurts their economy as you have tons of zombie companies. Or what people do is they take their money and buy apartments and rent them out on Airbnb, wrap them in a business, and get around the wealth tax.

The most effective way to tax wealth is to tax income, capital gains, and inheritance effectively.

But, lets say you can wave a magic wand and tax wealth (France already taxes real estate with a wealth tax + property tax).

What would a 2% yearly wealth tax raise? Maybe 15 to 25 billion a year in France, so it does nothing.

▲

JumpCrisscross a day ago | parent | prev [-]

> the proposal from the left is a 2% wealth tax annually on wealth above €100 million

Would this actually cover France's deficit?

	▲	bwb 11 hours ago \| parent [-]
		No, it is estimated that would only raise 15 to 25 billion. And people will just move, or move it around. France already has a wealth tax on real estate + property taxes.