Remix.run Logo
godelski 3 days ago

  > You are not entitled to protection from future competition
What do you think patents, copyright, trademarks, and all this other stuff is even about?

There's "Statutory Damages" which account for a wide range of things[0].

Not to mention you just completely ignored what I argued!

Seriously, you've been making a lot of very confident claims in this thread and they are easy to verify as false. Just google some of your assumptions before you respond. Hell, ask an LLM and they'll tell you! Just don't make assumptions and do zero amount of vetting. It's okay to be wrong, but you're way off base buddy.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Statutory_damages

vidarh 3 days ago | parent [-]

Copyright doesn't protect you from "future competition" in the sense meant here of competition from other works.

jimmydorry 3 days ago | parent [-]

Copyright protects you from market substitutions (e.g. someone taking your IP, and offering an alternative to your work). Being trained on your IP, it could certainly be argued that users would no longer need to purchase your book.

"Future competition" is a loosely worded way of saying this.

vidarh 3 days ago | parent [-]

"It could be argued" but the judge in this case has already ruled that the training does not violate copyright. Market substitution only comes into play to determine fair use if copyright has already been infringed.