Remix.run Logo
ThrowMeAway1618 4 days ago

>I’m curious to see where the Mamdani Experiment takes you all. His constituents are one group who are for certain no stranger to the armed presence reported elsewhere today. Under pretenses all too familiar.

What are you going on about? Mamdani may or may not be a good mayor for NYC. Ask me in two years.

But he's not some sort of jihadi, Commie pinko. He's a New Yorker who is actually talking about issues that New Yorkers care about.

It certainly helps that his competition are a disgraced serial sexual harasser (Cuomo), a corrupt sitting mayor whose administration (as well as himself) is riddled with corruption and a lack of accountability (Adams) and a clownish jerk whose claim to fame is that he used to ride the subways at night with his gang and beat up whoever they felt like (Sliwa).

Given the competition. is it any wonder that Mamdani is a cinch to win the mayoralty?

And all that has absolutely zero to do with the mud being slung at him. He will be the next mayor of NYC and I look forward to his tenure -- especially since it means the other folks will go away, at least for a few years.

Mamdani may suck at being mayor. I don't know. But it would be difficult for him to be worse than his field of opponents.

And none of that stuff has anything to do with national politics or the DNC.

I say all this as an old white guy of Jewish extraction.

I don't know where you're from or where you live, but you're talking out of your ass and it smells that way too. Yuck!

Edit: I may have, as anecdata (thanks for calling me out, anecdata!) suggested (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45193191 ), misunderstood your post. Upon reflection, I probably should have been more charitable in my reading of it. That said, you're flat wrong about Mamdani's "constituents." He, for the reasons I mentioned above, is supported not just by the minorities being targeted by the Trump administration, but by huge numbers of regular New Yorkers (of all ethnicities and melanin content levels), because he's the best candidate.

I'd add that Mamdani didn't just fly in from an Iranian terrorist training camp to run for mayor. He grew up in NYC, went to NYC public schools and has been an elected member of the New York State Assembly for the past four years.

If I misunderstood your comment as to Mamdani, his constituents (the residents of State Assembly District 36 in Queens), and/or his validity/viability as a mayoral candidate, my apologies.

dotnet00 4 days ago | parent | next [-]

They weren't attacking Mamdani, they were saying that it would be interesting how things play out, considering that, being a brown person, he's in the group of people that the RNC would love to toss into a camp before making them disappear.

ThrowMeAway1618 4 days ago | parent [-]

Yeah. I get that now.

It's an interesting, if horrifying thought -- stripping someone of their citizenship because folks don't like his religion and/or level of melanin.

It's disgusting.

I said it already, but I'll say it again -- I have no idea whether or not Mamdani will make a good mayor -- but he's far and away the best candidate in the race.

anecdatas 4 days ago | parent | prev [-]

I think the person you are responding to was suggesting Mamdani voters were likely the sort of people who are being targeted by the current administration. I think you might be misunderstanding their (admittedly obtuse) post.

ThrowMeAway1618 4 days ago | parent [-]

Thanks for pointing that out.

I should have been more charitable in my reading of GP's comment.

I've edited my comment to reflect that.