Remix.run Logo
utyop22 5 days ago

The reality is, language itself does not capture the entirety of what is really going on. And I'd get argue its the poorest way of expressing - but one that enables transmission through various mediums efficiently on a cost basis.

E.g. when I explain a concept, what comes to my mind is not a string of letters and words. There is a mix of imagery and even sounds that I may have acquired from learning about a concept - then I translate that into text so it can be communicated.

Theres a reason why people use native subtitles when watching netflix - text complements imagery and sounds.

kelnos 4 days ago | parent | next [-]

I use subtitles becomes sometimes I have trouble understanding the actors. I believe I read something that suggested that the sound mix in movies and cinematic TV shows has changed a lot in the past couple decades, and a result is that it's harder to understand dialogue.

I don't like this; I find my eyes spending more time than I'd like on the text, and not enough on the visual imagery on the rest of the screen. If I truly wanted more text, I'd just read a book.

pawelmurias 5 days ago | parent | prev [-]

I would assume most people use native subtitles when it's hard to understand what words the actors said.

ekianjo 5 days ago | parent | next [-]

Yeah because modern filmmakers make it very hard to hear dialogs for some reason and actors are encouraged to mumble. If I remember correctly even Nolan admitted it.

jibal 5 days ago | parent [-]

And they often speak very quickly--I often rewind to catch critical plot points. It's a lot different from a stage play, where actors enunciate so clearly. (Not that I want stage cadence and booming voices from a film ... they are different art forms.)

Also I watch of English language material that uses accents quite different from what my ears are tuned to.

jibal 5 days ago | parent | prev | next [-]

That's why I do.

TacticalCoder 5 days ago | parent | prev | next [-]

[dead]

utyop22 5 days ago | parent | prev [-]

No that is not the reason.

People watch Netflix to switch their brain off - having the text there helps along with the visual and sound to deliver the content. However, text is inferior to both visual and sound as a delivery mechanism.

keanebean86 5 days ago | parent [-]

Subtitles increase the signal to noise ratio. At least in our house. We have to keep the tv low to not wake the child. A volume of 10 with subtitles is similar to volume at 16 without subtitles.