Remix.run Logo
rstuart4133 5 days ago

> I don't follow; you can read the code that your LLM produces as well.

You can. You can also read the code a compiler produces perfectly well. In fact https://godbolt.org/ is a web site dedicated to programmers do just that. But ... how many programmers do you know who look at the assembler their compiler produces? In fact how many programmers do you know who understand the assembler?

Now lets extrapolate a bit. I've seen people say they've vibe coded a some program, yet they can't program. Did they read the code the LLM produced? Of course not. Did it matter? Apparently not for the program they produced.

Does the fact that they can vide program but not read code alter the types of programs they can produce? Of course it does. There limited to the sort of programs an LLM has seen before. Does that matter? Possibly not if the only programs they write are minor variations of what has been posted onto the internet already.

Now take two people, one who can only vide code, and another who knows how to program and understands computers at a very deep level. Ask yourself, who is going to be paid more? Is it the one who can only write programs that have been seen many times before by an LLM, or is it the one who can produce something truly new and novel?

yesbut 5 days ago | parent [-]

salary aside, the vibe coders are exposing themselves to increased cognitive decline which should be a strong enough incentive to avoid AI to begin with. maybe they already had a cognitive impairment before reading this MIT study and can't understand the risk.