Remix.run Logo
cj 2 days ago

> You're making my point even more

What exactly is your point?

Is your point that I should be smarter and shouldn’t have asked ChatGPT the question?

If that’s your point, understood, but I don’t think you can assume the average ChatGPT user will have such a discerning ability to determine when and when not using a LLM is appropriate.

FWIW I agree with you. But the “you shouldn’t ask ChatGPT that question” is a weak argument if you care about contextualizing and broadening your point beyond me and my specific anecdote.

BeetleB 2 days ago | parent [-]

My point is that if you're trying to demonstrate how unreliable LLMs are, this is a poor example, because the alternatives are almost equally poor.

> If that’s your point, understood, but I don’t think you can assume the average ChatGPT user will have such a discerning ability to determine when and when not using a LLM is appropriate.

I agree that the average user will not, but they also will not have the ability to determine that the answer from the top (few) Google links is invalid as well. All you've shown is the LLM is as bad as Google search results.

Put another way, if you invoke this as a reason one should not rely on LLMs (in general), then it follows one should not rely on Google either (in general).