Remix.run Logo
snapplebobapple 4 hours ago

The political pressure is budgetary and care related. Are you claiming MAID does not save money and decrease usage by ending expensive care earlier than it would otherwise be ended?

I would expect private care to uphold whatever I agreed to when buying insurance from them. You continue to miss the point that there is no other option in Canada because the government made the other options illegal, which is what creates the liability. They can't make care in any other form illegal and also not provide care. I am also talking about the specific case where the person is terminally ill, not the way more crazy version we have rolled out letting people with no impending doom opt for suicide. Limiting this to the defensible type of MAID limits the perverse incentive you are concerned about to almost nothing.

You trust the government to do the right thing when they have continually proven they will choose the wrong thing if it is convenient or the outcome most likely under incompetent management.

Eddy_Viscosity2 17 minutes ago | parent [-]

> Are you claiming MAID does not save money and decrease usage by ending expensive care earlier than it would otherwise be ended?

No, I'm saying it reduces suffering and it also saves money and resources. It's the first part that is the most important and where the political pressure came from. You seem to missing that point. That it reduces suffering and that people want suffering reduced!

End of life care is expensive regardless of whether it is publicly or privately funded. And in either cases there will be people in situations where extending life via medical means just isn't worth it because the extra time would just be an extension of torment. If private insurance was an option, then it would be the private company that would incentivized to get people to end life early. The private/public part is irrelevant to the discussion if you only look at it through a financial lens. Both ways would have the same incentive monetarily.

> You trust the government to do the right

In this case the right thing is to allow people to choose for themselves, and that it what's happening. I don't even know what you want instead, do you want MAID eliminated?