▲ | runarberg 2 days ago | |||||||
I don‘t think it is a spectrum either (if we are even more pedantic), or at least no a linear scale spectrum, but rather a system of government where democratic institutions ensure certain rights and privileges to common citizens and residents. So maybe a multidimensional spectrum where if you fail to meet a vaguely defined and constantly evolving threshold you are not a democracy. The USA today will probably (and hopefully) not be considered a democracy by some future standard. Disqualifications may include: * limited suffrage, * limited or unequal access to health care and education for a significant portion of the population, * convoluted voting system where certain demographics have little to no chance to pursue public office, * large constituencies, * non-state territories/districts with little to no representation at the national level, * unincorporated populated areas, with little to no representation at the local level, * a lack of clear separation of power between the different democratic institution, * failure to enact popular policies, * police violence, * the death penalty, * a large wealth gap, * a lack of consumer protection, * a lack of worker rights, * failure to prosecute the rich and powerful for their crimes, * a large nuclear armed military which constantly engages in imperialist actions, * failure to respect the sovereignty of other states, * etc. I think describing this system as a Democratic Republic offers no insight into whether it is democratic or not (or how democratic it is on this spectrum). Republic just means that there is a president which holds some the executive power. There is far more insight into calling the USA a capitalistic aristocracy, a two party state, a militaristic imperial superpower, a flawed, unequal, and underrepresented democracy, a police state, etc. | ||||||||
▲ | zahlman 15 hours ago | parent [-] | |||||||
> Disqualifications may include I don't see why; many of those have nothing to do with what I would understand the concept of "democracy" to entail. | ||||||||
|