> I spent a fair amount of time on it…

That's a red flag for me if true.

> …just saying "its bad" isn't really helpful feedback.

Not sure if serious, but you can start with these:

• Trademark misuse – Legal exposure, identity confusion, invites takedown

• Gmail contact address – Unprofessional, lacks credibility, signals amateur status

• Anonymous "we" – No trust, no track record, only named person using alt email

• Lovable-generated site – Bad looking, substance-free, designed to farm email addresses

None of this is actually needed to get validation.

Would me having domain email routing somehow make it more legit? No it wouldn’t, I’ve now gotten validation that people like the idea without doing any of that, which is the exact advice that y combinator gives, yet is never followed in HN comments