Remix.run Logo
numpy-thagoras 3 days ago

It's part of a dependency relation, the function computes and produces an output that we call sqrt(2).

On the other hand, using the axioms of ZFC, one can say any real number exists without having a function to compute it, or a proof to construct it.

For an ultrafinitist, or any finitist for that matter, we say that you only need the minimum of ingredients to produce math -- you do not need to assume anything over and above that, as it's not even helpful in the verification process.

So assuming only finitely many symbols and finitely many numbers, I can produce what we call sqrt(2). We only ever verify it numerically and finitely anyways. We can never reach decimals at infinite ordinals.

So it makes no sense to say, "Hey I assume transfinitely many entities, and my assumption says these numbers exist even though the proofs and decimal expansions are only ever finite."