It's the same scam selling ideas that sound good to people who don't understand what a "joule" as Pavegen and the other systems that generate energy from footfall or passing cars. Mechanical energy is pretty "low grade" as energy goes.

It 100% works, but it's a system that has very specific applications and doesn't scale up well. And the best systems use a magical property of some fairly heavy materials called "being liquid" to simplify the logistics of getting millions of tonnes of weight to the lifting mechanism.

▲

bjoli 2 days ago | parent [-]

One of them is moving almost seven thousand 25-tonne concrete blocks around. I can't see how it would ever compete with something like compressed air.

It just seems so awfully wasteful.

If someone can find some real costs I would be more than happy.

▲

grues-dinner a day ago | parent [-]

7000 * 25t / 2.5t/m^3 = 70,000m^3 of water. So about 1% of the water storage of Dinorwig, which runs dry in about 6 hours of use.

Now, I know reservoirs are ecologically pretty iffy, expensive and obviously geographically sensitive, so you can't slap them around everywhere. But all these mechanical schemes have big "look what they need to mimic a fraction of our power" vibes!

I could imagine that steel-on-steel block movements could actually be quite efficient and effective in limited scenarios, but logistically it just seems like a lot of squeeze for not a lot of juice considering how much power is required to be stored for utility-scale projects. I would like to say that that they're just delusional people truly hoping it'll work, but I think there's a core of hard-nosed scammers who smell money for a shiny PPT and a plausible-to-non-engineers Wile E. Coyote/Troll Physics contraption with big numbers in the brochure: 7000 blocks! 25 tonnes per block! Megajoules! Efficiencies! Scale! Repurposed coal mining infrastructure! They even have AI in the spiel now: https://www.energyvault.com/solutions/software

Or maybe it'll work and I'll look stupid in 30 years when there are huge fields of hundreds of kilometre-deep boreholes with 100 kilotonne masses moving up and down in them. But somehow it seems quite unlikely on a practical level considering the cost of boring gigantic holes that you'd have to do to make it scale. Onsies-twosie installations in a few mines here and there may work for lucky outlying towns, but they aren't civilisational scale solutions.

	▲	bjoli 10 hours ago \| parent [-]
		Oh, but only at about 145 meters. Dinorvig has a fall of over 300m.