It sounds just as unfair as including a levy on blank CDs paid to music copyright holders, regardless of how the CDs are used. But being unfair doesn't mean it can't happen in your country.

▲

diggan 4 days ago | parent | next [-]

Flashback to Sweden, around 2011 or so. Copyright owners convince the government to add a $/GB levy to digital storage mediums like USBs, just in case people would use it for storing copyrighted material. The kicker? Personally archiving copyrighted material to your personal storage is (was?) fully allowed by law, but somehow it went through anyways. Glad I don't live there anymore :)

▲

throawayonthe 4 days ago | parent | prev [-]

holy shit it's real

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Private_copying_levy

▲

ipaddr 4 days ago | parent | next [-]

Which then allows you to download without being sued because you already paid.

▲

moefh 4 days ago | parent [-]

No, it doesn't. From that Wikipedia entry:

> A common misconception is that levies are compensation for illegal copying such as file sharing. This is incorrect, however, levies are only intended to compensate for private copying that is legally allowed in many jurisdictions. For example, uploading a purchased CD on to another personal device such as a laptop or MP3 player.

"Private copying" is generally allowed under copyright law -- except that under DMCA, it's only allowed if you're not circumventing DRM. So for example, you can legally make a private copy of a CD, but not a Blu-ray disc.

▲

dragonwriter 4 days ago | parent [-]

> "Private copying" is making private copies of is generally allowed under copyright law -

Private copying is not generally allowed, but private copying levies tend to be adopted alongside specific exceptions for certain cases of private copying in the copyright law of the jurisdiction adopting them (e.g., in the US, those in the Audio Home Recording Act.)

▲

moefh 4 days ago | parent [-]

Right, what I meant is that private copying is allowed because these levies exist -- but the fact that they exist only allows you to make private copies, not (as was stated) download anything.

	▲	subscribed 4 days ago \| parent [-]
		Depends on the jurisdiction. In several personal use rights are broad enough to download almost anything (eg except software or databases), and the levy is explicitly described in law as a compensation.

▲

hahn-kev 4 days ago | parent | prev [-]

Wow