Remix.run Logo
Frieren a day ago

Any capability that we lose as a society is going to be hard to get back.

I understand that AI companies want to embed AI in everything and make society dependent on it. Like cigarette brands AI companies want a world addicted to their technology.

But as a society we should be more careful before throwing well known methods for fancy new tech. Even more important is to take a step back and think when AI companies are pushing for "not lose the AI race", "speed up adoption", and the rest of FOMO scaremongering.

Stop and think is what I expect from professionals even when CEOs push for AI as fast as possible.

jf22 12 hours ago | parent | next [-]

Has technology made us lose any capabilities so far?

Everywhere I look there is someone preserving 16th century cave painting techniques or hand tanning beavers and then writing guides that surpass whatever knowledge there was centuries ago.

MeetingsBrowser 2 hours ago | parent | next [-]

> Everywhere I look there is someone preserving ...

You don't know what you don't know. Just because you know of some things being preserved doesn't mean all knowledge is being preserved.

For example, the US has lost its ability to do all sorts of manufacturing.

Businesses don't tend to document internal processes publicly. As those businesses die out and the people who worked for them retire, there is no one left to pass the skills along.

That's why the Army always keeps one tank factory open. So the knowledge and skills are not lost.

sejje 11 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

I'm kind-of into old techniques and crafting styles. I live in the forest, so it kind of lends itself to that.

I agree with you. I have piles of books detailing very old crafts like processing game, tanning hides, trapping, hunting. Knapping stone tools, weaving baskets, raising pole barns, distilling whiskey at home, making clothes, mending clothes, herbal/wild medicines. The foxfire books being a great example of how we preserve this knowledge.

Almost anything modern we've learned is going to be well-documented IMO. We may not be referencing those documents any longer, but they exist, and will exist for a long time.

And also agree that modern methods tend to be better, or at least the best version of the old methods is widely known, thanks to youtube etc. Primitive Technology on youtube, for instance, was able to launch himself into the iron age without bringing any modern tools along. But the access to modern informational sources makes him a primitive powerhouse.

jxntb73 20 hours ago | parent | prev [-]

Like past bubbles, it’s usefulness is being marketed into existence.