Remix.run Logo
bearl 6 days ago

Links to pii are by far the worst sort of pii, yes.

“It’s not his actual money, it’s just his bank account and routing number.”

djoldman 6 days ago | parent | next [-]

A more accurate analogy is "it's not his actual money, it's a link to a webpage or image that has his bank account and routing number."

bearl 6 days ago | parent [-]

My contention is that links to pii are themselves pii.

A name, Jon Smith, is technically PII but not very specific. If I have a link to a specific Jon Smith’s facebook page or his HN profile, it’s even more personally identifiable than knowing his name is Jon Smith.

Ferret7446 5 days ago | parent [-]

That is crazy. The target of a link could change, which means that all links are Schroedinger's PII.

And if a link to PII is PII, then a link to a link to PII is PII, and thus all links are PII unless it links to the dark (unlinked) Web

atemerev 5 days ago | parent | prev [-]

Well yes, by knowing my bank account and routing number, you don't have access to my money.

Cheer2171 5 days ago | parent [-]

You do in the US.

atemerev 3 days ago | parent [-]

That sounds insecure. Looks like blockchain and private keys with extra hops. Perhaps you can easily revert banking transactions...