I've tried that but it isn't very effective because usually if they are not a git wizard, they are already using some sort of git interface or GUI that prevents them from making catastrophic mistakes. So they don't see the appeal in relearning all their git knowledge and terminology.

Hence why I initially try to sell it as an addition to their toolbox, instead of as a replacement for their entire workflow.

I agree with you both.

Jj makes mistakes hard, but also makes it easy to just focus on your code and easily sort out anything git-related later as an after-thought.