Remix.run Logo
dudeinjapan 16 hours ago

I think “confabulation” is the best term.

“Hallucination” is seeing/saying something that a sober person clearly knows is not supposed to be there, e.g. “The Vice President under Nixon was Oscar the Grouch.”

Harry Frankfurt defines “bullshitting” as lying to persuade without regard to the truth. (A certain current US president does this profusely and masterfully.)

“Confabulation” is filling the unknown parts of a statement or story with bits that sound as-if they could be true, i.e. they make sense within the context, but are not actually true. People with dementia (e.g. a certain previous US president) will do this unintentionally. Whereas the bullshitter generally knows their bullshit to be false and is intentionally deceiving out of self-interest, confabulation (like hallucination) can simply be the consequence of impaired mental capacity.

nicce 14 hours ago | parent [-]

I think the Frankfurt definition is a bit off.

E.g. from the paper ChatGPT is bullshit [1],

> Frankfurt understands bullshit to be characterized not by an intent to deceive but instead by a reckless disregard for the truth.

That is different than defining "bullshitting" as lying. I agree that "confabulation" could otherwise be more accurate. But with previous definition they are kinda synonyms? And "reckless disregard for the truth" may hit closer. The paper has more direct quotes about the term.

[1] https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10676-024-09775-5