Remix.run Logo
numpad0 2 days ago

I just can't understand why "[specialized domain] uses these stupid wrong units, it should be [unit that no educated smart SMEs use]" types don't do their researches to understand why those are used at all. This type of weird non-SI units appear when means of measurement and unit is related to one another and has downstream dependencies.

Just look at aviation. An airplane's:

  - speed is measured in knots, or minute of angle of latitude per hour, which is measured by ratio of static and dynamic pressure as a proxy.
  - vertical speed or rate of climb is measured in feet per minute, which is a leaky pressure gauge, probably all designed in inches.
  - altitude is measured in feet, through pressure, which scale is corrected by local barometric pressures advertised on radio, with the fallback default of 29.92 inHg. When they say "1000ft" vertical separation, it's more like 1 inHg or 30 hPa of separation.
  - engine power is often measured in "N1 RPM %" in jet engines, which obviously has nothing to do with anything. It's an rev/minutes figure of a windmilling shaft in an engine. Sometimes it's EPR or Engine Pressure Ratio or pressure ratio between intake and exhaust. They could install a force sensor on the engine mount but they don't.
  - tire pressure is psi or pound per square inch, screw tightening torques MAY be N-m, ft-lbs, or in-lbs, even within a same machine. 
Sure, you can design a battery charging circuits in Joules, fly an airplane with a GPS speedometer, analog audio-radio circuitry in millivolts. Absolutely no one does. I think that cognitive dissonance should trigger curiosity circuitry, not rant mode.

I mean, just type in "use of decibels[dB] considered harmful" at the box at chatgpt.com. It'll generate basically this article with an armchair version of the top comment here as the conclusion.

anilakar 2 days ago | parent [-]

Wait until you hear about unit conversions in aeronautical mental math. 1 NM across ground corresponds to 1000 or 100 feet of altitude in many conversion formulas. For small angles, sines and tangents are approximated by degrees of azimuth × distance in NM = 60.